|
Summary
|
Contracting
parties will often agree to
waive a trial by jury in event of a dispute
California's
Supreme Court held that contractual waivers are invalid under California law
(2005)
|
Contractual Waivers Invalid Under California Law
SEC_CODE_REF_0090001192884
|
Grafton
Partners v Superior Court (CA Sup 2005)
- Opinion
(California Supreme Court)
California Code of Civil Procedure § 631
controls
- Provides limited and exclusive means to waive
trail by jury
- Doesn't allow for predispute contractual waiver
Overturns 1991 intermediate appellate court
decision
- Trizec Properties v Superior Court (1991)
229 Cal.App.3d 1616
Unanimous decision based on California
constitutional principles
- Acknowledges that most other jurisdictions allow
for contractual waiver provided waiver is knowing and voluntary
- See footnote 12 of the opinion
|
|